Cheating? Plagiarism? Or just a helpful tool?

Give this a try. Thesis Builder and Online Outliner. Pretty amazing. Is it cheating or just a helpful tool? I tend to think it is cheating – but I am open to hearing other opinions.

An online citation maker like EasyBib is a useful tool because it saves you from a tedious task – a task which has no real intrinsic value as far as I can see. But a site that will write your thesis statement for you….? I don’t know….. I suppose it does have some value in teaching kids how keywords and concepts can be synthesized into a thesis statement. But once the kids discover this – will they ever write an original thesis statement again? Isn’t thesis building a critical thinking skill? Exercising our brains keeps them “lean and sharp”. Are American brains in danger of becoming as flabby as their bodies?

There are no shortcuts to a healthy brain anymore than there are any shortcuts to a healthy body. Pass the chocolate please. Maybe the Internet really IS “mind candy”?!

Research? Fun? Did I hear that right?

Just had to report on my last two very exciting days. Last year we started a new 10th grade research project, hoping to teach the research process along with 21st century skills AND get the kids interested in “flat world”, global issues. It was a learning experience – mostly successful as far as it went. This year the teachers and I are revamping it to make it more collaborative. We have the students researching with the ultimate goal of writing group research papers on globalization or global warming, and also creating presentations as groups.

Yesterday and today I showed up in English classes to do my introduction to library research. Teenage groans all around. Although the students had done some background reading – they had not really grasped the breadth of subjects covered under the term “globalization”. Mostly, they did not appear to have any personal connection to the whole thing. So – the big challenge was to get them interested.

In my introduction, I use Karl Fisch’s wonderful work (remixed into a video by Scott McLeod) – Did You Know.

It is fascinating to see student reactions. Many find it frightening. Some of them see the challenges as exciting. All of them find the video mesmerizing. I love listening to their reactions and leading them in a brainstorming session. What are the problems? What are the challenges? What are the opportunities? Slowly they begin to realize that many of the topics near and dear to their hearts will ultimately provide ways for them to excel in a global society. Not to mention get them through the research process without dying of that dreaded teenage disease – Boredom. What a transformation!

Overheard during brainstorming and during research time:

“We really are allowed to research YouTube?

“Are you serious, we can write about “Gaming?”
“I did a presentation at my church about hunger in Africa – – I’d love to do more about that!”

“I know a LOT about MySpace – I could do THAT!!”

“We want to learn about YouTube. Can we create our own video and post it, and then track how many people see it and make some charts?”

“The period is over already? This was fun – it didn’t feel like research at all!”

Was everything a librarian/teacher’s dream?

Heck no. We learned that forming groups can be a problem for students. The social angst in one class was quite palpable. After that class, we changed tactics. The rest of the classes were told that they would eventually be forming groups. However, to begin with they were to do preliminary research on the topics they were individually interested in. Next they were to complete a form to help them develop research questions and keywords. Those were due at the end of the period and we, the teachers, would use the results to create the groups. Depending on how that all falls out – we will have groups varying in size from 2 to 4.

We’ll see how it goes. Right now – it is exciting to see enthusiasm!

Yup! Summer Really Is Over….

I took the summer off from blogging and then school got started. No time to blog for the first 2 weeks of the annual craziness. I am beginning to get into a pattern again. But I have to say – I really resent letting those lazy days of summer go…. Actually – there really were no lazy days except when we went to the Adirondacks to camp. We HAVE to go there to maintain our sanity. We’ve been doing a lot of work on the house and that really sucked up our “lazy” time at home.

Anyway….What made me really know that summer is over? Well – I printed out this article:

Tags Help Make Libraries Del.icio.us [Library Journal]

As always I am quite intigued by Library 2.0 concepts and how we can use them to make our students’ library experiences better. As I read, my brain is making a list of ways that I can use social bookmarking. For one thing – it would be a terrific addition to our upcoming 10th grade research project on Globalization. My list has 4 or 5 uses on it and I am only half way through page 1 of the article. And then it hits me. There is no way I can do anything on the list. Why? Not enough time? Prefer my static web page? Think my students won’t be interested? Nooooo….

The #%^$ content filter raises it’s ugly head. It’s a case of “we just can’t get there from here” – at least not at school. Here we are again. A wonderfully adaptable (and free!) tool shot down by our overzealous need to protect our children and our networks.

I DO understand our need to protect. Really I do. I’ve seen the Dateline episodes too (And aren’t they just a voyeur’s dream?)

Could there be an answer to my dilemma? Blogging used to be impossible in school – but eventually the filters recognized that there are some student-friendly blog providers (edublogs, classroom blogmeister etc.).

Are there any social bookmarking sites designed specifically for students? I hope to find out about some. PLEASE SHARE WHAT YOU KNOW. Thanks!!

Students 1.0?

In the comment section of a recent post, Doug Johnson refers to himself as Doug 1.0 because he had printed out an article to read later. It got me thinking…. Are there any studies available that measure reading comprehension levels of material read in hard copy vs. material read on a computer screen? I have speculated on this before – but so far have not found a study. Probably ineffective search methods.

I am interested because most of my students (grade 9-12) prefer reading printed articles, rather than reading them online. Does that make them Students 1.0 – or do they instinctively know that when they need to read “deeply”, the printed word works better for them than the digital word? Or maybe they just like to kill trees and bug the library staff to change the ink cartridge….

Best thing you did this year?

There is a discussion going on over at LM_NET right now. Someone asked “What is the best thing you did this year?”

Here it is for me – probably the best project I have ever had the privilege to work on.

I participated in GatesBeatles – a committee with a funny name dedicated to:

  • Free-range brainstorming
  • Studying trends
  • Discovering the needs of 21st century learners
  • Re-imagining what a school should be
  • Trying out ideas

Kudos to our visionary principal Ken Dehn who made this committee a reality. He is retiring when this school year ends and this exhilarating committee is one of his many legacies. Thanks also to Doug Johnson and David Warlick whose writings have fueled our enthusiasm for the past 18 months or so.

Our committee tried an experiment. We designed an Academic Challenge Event for our students:

Who:

  • Two 12-student teams of all abilities & grade levels on each team
  • 4 teacher facilitators per team

THE CHALLENGE:

  • Stay within a budget to build a home
  • Create a virtual model of an energy efficient, environmentally friendly home
  • Meet local building codes
  • Make the home accessible for the physically challenged
  • Include recreational features to make the home appealing for a family
  • Market the plan to a team of judges

THE RESOURCES:

  • A real estate agent
  • A banker
  • An architect
  • A contractor
  • An attorney
  • A code enforcement officer
  • 3-D Architect Software
  • Cell phones, ipods etc.
  • Virtual Home Building (Online Library Pathfinder)

THE TIME FRAME:

  • 2 school days
  • First day – viewed potential building lots and met with building experts
  • Second day – under 6 hours to actually create the virtual home

THE RESULTS?

Beyond our WILDEST dreams


To learn more, you can read about this project (and more) on a PowerpPoint I created for a recent workshop.

Please click on the Globalization PowerPoint link on this web page:

ACADEMIC CHALLENGE EVENT

In addition to the PowerPoint, there are links to the many documents that were created to get this project up and running. We hope to create more challenges in the future as we examine ways to make learning more “real world” for our students.